My Daughter Hates Me: If a child dies isn’t it the mother’s fault? (Part 9 of 13)

Growing up in the hill country of West Virginia my dad is full of colloquialisms. He is constantly saying things like, “That’s slicker than an eel in a bucket of snot,” or this thing or that is “slower than molasses”. On more than one occasion he has suggested not coming between, “a she-bear and her cubs”. I imagine that is good advice if you are fishing in bear country during trout season. It is also good advice when discussing our daughter and her mother.

From the beginning, Betty argued my relationship with Cassie was a package deal. Either accept both of them or forget having a relationship with my daughter. Regardless of whether that is “right”, it is reality. It is exactly how it turned out. I don’t like it but I long ago accepted it.

As stated earlier, I was angry with Betty for coming between my daughter and me. As such, I responded by withholding child support and threatening to get a lawyer and sue. I would steamroll her if she didn’t stop interfering in my relationship with my daughter. After all, Cassandra is my daughter and I have my “rights”. See the pattern.

Not once did Betty and I talk about what was best for our daughter. In the end, my pride and arrogance did far more damage to my relationship with Cassie then Betty ever could.

As I said earlier, I believe Mason Cooley is right when he said, “The beginning of self-knowledge: recognizing that your motives are the same as other people’s.” The only conclusion I can draw is my daughter’s mother’s motives are the same as mine, she was angry with me because I was coming between her and Cassie. From my perspective, we both did and said a lot in an attempt to protect our “rights”. Truthfully, it would have been better if I had focused less on my “rights” and more on my “responsibility”. It would have made my fifty percent less messy.

In hindsight, I cannot blame Betty for her actions. I certainly cannot hate her. I threatened to get a court order taking custody of Cassie. I imagine she was just as terrified of a sheriff showing up at her door taking Cassandra away from her as I was of the sheriff showing up at my door with an arrest warrant because of past due child support. Immaturity wreaks havoc on the mind creating unreasonable fears.

Living in fear is horrible, whether human or bear, and I guess we both instinctively do what have to do to protect our children. We do what seems “right” regardless of what is “best”.

For example, over the years, I’ve heard stories of firemen needing to drag mothers out of a flame-engulfed house because they refuse to leave until the baby is found. Sounds “right” but if the mother dies is that “best” for the surviving children? Is it “best” for the mother? I have a female friend who argues that the “right” in that situation is irrelevant. It is what is expected and the societal shame is a heavy burden for a grieving mother.

After all, my friend asks, if a child dies isn’t it perceived as the mother’s fault?

As a discarded dad, I have a unique perspective on children. Not the “right” one just a unique one. For example, I have friends who have divorced and fought over the children the same way they fought over the Roth IRA or the house. They make the issue who contributed what and for how long. They treat their children as a possession instead of individuals. They use the children as a weapon for leverage. Having lost the bond to my daughter I know better. Broken and lost possessions can be replaced. Broken and lost relationships can never be replaced. You will always carry the sadness.

I heard a wise grandmother say to me her children are individuals of her not because of her. They are gifts from the Universe and simply passed through her womb. Her responsibility is to care for them until they can care for themselves. She tries to teach them how to love and be loved. How to live fearlessly.

I like that because that is what I want for my daughter. I want her to be able to love and be loved. I want her to be fearless by courageously facing the dangers and challenges of life. Honestly, that is all I want for myself. For my ex-wife. For Betty. For everyone I’ve ever been angry with. For everyone I know. I’ve never met you but it is what I want for you.

I talked to a number of individuals with similar experiences, and sought their advice about my situation with Betty and my daughter. Generally, the solution was variations on the same themes:

“Get a lawyer and sue.”
“Get a lawyer and fight for your rights.”
“She has a right to be with her father.”
“Women are bitches. Pay your support and move on.”


When I’m honest, it seemed to me it would make a bad situation worse. After all, how can I argue in good faith for my “rights” when I did such a lousy job addressing my responsibilities? I wasn’t accountable when Betty was pregnant. Later, I neglected my financial obligations out of childish anger, false pride and unbridled ambition. Truthfully, it seems I lack the credibility to be demanding my “rights”.


  1. Hey Sean, checked your article out after you sent it my way on Twitter. I will do some catching up on the blog series when I get time and learn more about your (lack of) relationship with your daughter, but I come into this article from the other side of things, as the daughter who severed ties with her father, though (hopefully, and it seems from what you’ve said in this post) for very different reasons.


  2. Hey sean, I have been on both ends of this my Father left my mother when I was 3 boy that was rough he did not pay child support ever. nor did I know him until I was 15. my mother drove me from Arizona to Idaho and dropped me on his door step in the middle of the night, cause I was a brat. lol anyways, I have been here in Idaho ever since with my Father who is amazing. then he ends up showing me canceled checks a (brief case full) of the years of child support he paid WOW I was floored. Now I am a single mother of 4. there ages are 21, 19, 18, and almost 10. My 10 yr old is Brandon his father has never ever paid child support and rarely sees Brandon. my heart breaks for him cause I grew up without a father, and there is now a pattern what do you do?? Honestly I would have wanted my father in my life instead of child support at this point Brandon would rather have his father in his life instead too. I just have to say you writing is very inspiring. and your brutal honesty is even more heart warming


  3. Oh I forgot my point lol sorry. my point is I grew up hating my father cause I really did not know him, a lot of it was my mother’s opinion and since my father was not really around to defend himself I had just that to go on. It turns out my father is an amazing man, father, and grandfather. I think you have made some mistakes Sean but it is not too late to do something about it you know. and its so obvious you love your daughter dearly. I commend you.


  4. This is a great series. It seems like it should be so easy, and yet it’s a very hard thing to always choose what is right for your child over what is right for you. It shouldn’t be and it’s unflattering to admit this, but the emotions in a divorce cloud things. I wish more people would talk about this.


    1. Hi Tara,
      Thanks. I’m happy you are getting something out of it for yourself too. We don’t talk about it enough. It’s no wonder so many of us grow up emotionally illiterate. What needs talked about is replaced with baseball scores and pop cultural references. Being vulnerable requires talking a risk. Taking a risk means the possibility of failure. Failure is a dead albatross wrapped around a person’s neck. I’m a failure as a parent and a father. My relationship with my daughter and her mother reeks of failure. However, the truth is, I’m only as sick as my secrets and one day I will be judged for those secrets. I’m tired of living in shame. I hope this series helps cut those cords for myself and others. We all have our sins – these are mine.
      Thank you again.


  5. Great post! Thought provoking and spot on! As a mother and a step-mum its very hard in the heat of the moment to be honest, mature and do whats right for everyone.

    Looking forward to see more posts!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s